When choosing kitchen scissors, most people naturally pay attention to the blades. Their sharpness, shape and intended use are important, but the handles can make just as much difference to how comfortable the scissors feel.
Two common designs are all-stainless-steel scissors, where both the blades and handles are made from metal, and resin-handled scissors, which combine metal blades with plastic or rubber-like grips.
Both are widely used by Japanese kitchen-scissor manufacturers, and each has its advantages.
All-stainless scissors appeal to people who prefer a solid, straightforward construction that's easy to clean. Resin-handled models offer more flexibility in handle shape, grip and overall weight.
I wouldn't consider either material universally better. The right choice depends on how often you use your scissors, what you're cutting and what feels most comfortable in your hand.
What's the Difference Between All-Stainless and Resin-Handled Scissors?
The main difference is how the handles are constructed.
All-stainless-steel kitchen scissors have metal handles rather than separate plastic or rubber coverings. On designs such as the KAI DH3346, each half is forged from stainless steel, creating a continuous structure between the blade and handle.
This gives the scissors a clean, substantial appearance without the material junctions found on many conventional designs.
Resin-handled kitchen scissors use stainless-steel blades combined with handles made from a synthetic material.
However, resin isn't one specific material. Manufacturers use several types, including:
- ABS resin: A relatively rigid plastic that allows handles to be moulded into practical, ergonomic shapes.
- Elastomer: A more flexible, rubber-like material that can provide a softer, more secure grip.
- Specialist resins: Materials selected for particular characteristics, such as heat resistance or antibacterial properties.
These differences matter. An ABS handle won't necessarily feel as soft as an elastomer grip, even though both fall under the broader category of non-metal handles.
The Benefits of All-Stainless Kitchen Scissors
A Simple Construction That's Easy to Clean
One of the strongest arguments for all-stainless scissors is their straightforward construction.
When the blade and handle form one continuous metal piece, there aren't separate plastic components attached to the handles. This removes some of the material junctions where food residue and moisture might otherwise collect.
It's particularly useful for scissors that regularly come into contact with raw meat, poultry or fish.
However, an all-stainless design doesn't eliminate the need to clean around the pivot. That's still an area where residue can accumulate, regardless of the handle material.
If the scissors are also detachable, you get the additional benefit of being able to separate the blades and clean the overlapping surfaces more thoroughly.
A Solid, Substantial Feel
All-stainless scissors often have a firmer, more substantial feel than lighter resin-handled designs.
Some people prefer this because the extra weight can make the scissors feel stable and controlled.
The KAI DH3346, for example, weighs approximately 158 g and uses a forged all-stainless construction. Its curved blades and substantial handles are designed for regular food preparation.
However, weight is largely a matter of preference. A heavier pair may feel reassuringly solid to one person but unnecessarily cumbersome to another.
I wouldn't choose all-stainless scissors simply because they feel more substantial. The size and weight still need to suit the tasks you're performing.
No Separate Resin Handle Components
A well-made all-stainless pair doesn't have plastic or elastomer handle coverings that could potentially loosen, crack or deteriorate over time.
This can be an advantage for someone looking for a simple tool intended for long-term use.
However, stainless steel isn't indestructible. The blades can still become damaged, the pivot can wear, and corrosion can develop if the scissors aren't properly maintained.
The absence of resin handles removes one possible point of deterioration, but it doesn't guarantee a longer lifespan.
The Drawbacks of All-Stainless Kitchen Scissors
The Handles Can Feel Less Comfortable
The main disadvantage is that metal handles don't provide the cushioning of softer grip materials.
During longer cutting sessions, particularly when working with tougher ingredients, a rigid handle can place more pressure on your fingers.
This doesn't mean all-stainless scissors are necessarily uncomfortable. Well-shaped finger openings can distribute pressure effectively, and some people prefer the firmer feel.
However, if comfort is your main priority, I'd pay particular attention to the handle shape rather than assuming an all-metal design will suit your hand.
They Can Be Heavier
Although there are exceptions, all-stainless models often weigh more than similarly sized scissors with lightweight resin handles.
That extra weight may not be noticeable during occasional use, but it can become more relevant when repeatedly cutting ingredients or working for longer periods.
For someone who mainly wants scissors for herbs, vegetables and everyday kitchen tasks, a lighter pair may be easier to manoeuvre.
Metal Handles Can Become Slippery
Smooth stainless-steel handles may provide less grip when your hands are wet or oily.
The severity depends on the handle shape, surface finish and how securely your fingers fit inside the openings.
Metal also conducts heat more readily than resin. Neither design should be left against hot cookware, but all-metal handles can become uncomfortable to touch if exposed to a hot surface.
These aren't necessarily major disadvantages during normal use, but they're worth considering.
The Benefits of Resin-Handled Kitchen Scissors
More Comfortable Grip Options
The biggest advantage of resin-handled scissors is the freedom manufacturers have to shape the handles.
Rather than following the shape of a metal loop, resin can be moulded into larger openings, curved grips or asymmetrical designs that better accommodate the hand.
Some materials, particularly elastomers, also provide a softer surface that can feel more comfortable during repeated cutting.
The Green Bell SJ-K100 is a good example.
Its curved elastomer handles are shaped to fit comfortably in the hand, while the stainless-steel blades provide the cutting performance needed for everyday food preparation.
I think this is one of the strongest reasons to consider resin-handled scissors. A comfortable grip can matter considerably more than whether the handles are made from metal or plastic.
Often Lighter and Easier to Handle
Resin-handled scissors can also be lighter, particularly when the manufacturer has designed them around everyday use.
For example, the Green Bell SJ-K100 weighs approximately 100 g, noticeably less than the 158 g KAI DH3346.
That difference may be useful if you regularly cut herbs, vegetables or smaller ingredients where a compact, manageable tool is preferable.
However, resin doesn't automatically mean lightweight.
The Silky NDS-270C, for example, has ABS-resin handles but weighs approximately 186 g because of its oversized construction and long blades.
Overall size and blade construction can influence weight just as much as the handle material.
More Choice in Handle Design
Resin allows manufacturers to create specialised handles without necessarily changing the basic blade construction.
This can be particularly useful for scissors intended for specific users or tasks.
Some designs have oversized finger openings, while others use curved handles to provide a more natural grip.
There are also resin-handled scissors made specifically for left-handed users, with the handle shape and blade orientation designed around left-handed cutting.
The material itself doesn't make the scissors more precise, but it gives manufacturers greater flexibility in how the tool is held and operated.
The Drawbacks of Resin Handles
The main disadvantage is that resin components can potentially deteriorate over time.
Depending on the material and how the scissors are treated, handles may become scratched, discoloured, cracked or damaged by excessive heat.
Softer elastomer grips may also show wear differently from harder ABS handles.
Another consideration is cleaning. Some resin handles have joints or narrow gaps where the handle material meets the metal, which may require additional attention when washing.
This doesn't make resin-handled scissors inherently unhygienic. A well-designed pair can be straightforward to clean, particularly if the blades are detachable.
It's also worth remembering that some resin-handled scissors aren't dishwasher-safe. Others are specifically designed to tolerate machine washing, so the manufacturer's instructions should always take priority.
Examples from Japanese Kitchen Scissors
Looking at actual models makes the differences easier to understand.
Swipe horizontally to view all columns →
| Model | Handle Material | Weight | Detachable |
|---|---|---|---|
| KAI DH3346 | Stainless steel | 158 g | Yes |
| Shimomura Pro Grade PG-411 | Stainless steel | 140 g | Yes |
| Green Bell SJ-K100 | Elastomer | 100 g | Yes |
| Shimomura Pro Grade PG-402 | ABS resin | 102 g | Yes |
Explore All Japanese Kitchen Scissors →
The KAI DH3346 and Shimomura PG-411 demonstrate two approaches to all-stainless construction. Both use metal handles and detachable blades, providing a straightforward design for cleaning and maintenance.
The Green Bell SJ-K100 and Shimomura PG-402 take a different approach, combining stainless-steel blades with shaped handles made from elastomer and ABS resin respectively.
Both are also detachable, showing that easy-clean construction isn't limited to all-metal scissors.
The PG-402 is particularly interesting because its curved blades, large resin handles and relatively light 102 g weight offer a different combination of features from the heavier KAI design.
These models aren't identical in their cutting capabilities, so I wouldn't treat them as a direct performance comparison. They simply demonstrate how different manufacturers balance construction, comfort and weight.
Which Handle Material Is Easier to Keep Clean?
All-stainless scissors have an advantage when the blades and handles form a seamless structure.
With no separate resin handle components, there are fewer material junctions to inspect when cleaning.
However, detachable construction can be just as important.
A resin-handled pair with detachable blades may be easier to clean around the pivot than an all-stainless pair with a permanently fixed joint.
It's also worth distinguishing handle material from dishwasher suitability.
For example, the KAI DH3346 and Green Bell SJ-K100 are both listed as dishwasher-safe despite using different handle materials.
By contrast, the Silky KSP-220 has antibacterial resin handles but requires hand-washing.
Antibacterial handle materials don't remove the need to clean the scissors thoroughly after use, particularly when preparing raw food.
For more detailed cleaning advice, see our guide to whether kitchen scissors can go in the dishwasher.
Are All-Stainless Scissors Stronger?
Not necessarily. An all-stainless design can offer a robust construction, particularly when the blades and handles are forged from steel.
However, the strength and cutting performance of kitchen scissors depend on several factors beyond the handle material.
These include blade thickness, steel quality, pivot construction, cutting-edge shape and the amount of leverage provided by the handles.
A well-made resin-handled pair can be perfectly suitable for demanding food preparation.
For example, the Green Bell G-2035 combines thick stainless-steel blades with elastomer handles and is intended for heavier-duty kitchen tasks.
I'd therefore avoid using handle material as a shortcut for judging strength.
It's more useful to check what the manufacturer designed the scissors to cut.
All-Stainless vs Resin Handles: Which Should You Choose?
I would generally consider all-stainless kitchen scissors if you:
- Prefer a firm, substantial feel.
- Want a simple construction without separate resin grips.
- Regularly prepare food and value straightforward cleaning.
- Don't mind slightly heavier scissors or rigid metal handles.
Resin-handled kitchen scissors may be preferable if you:
- Prioritise grip comfort.
- Want a lighter, more manageable pair.
- Prefer larger or more ergonomically shaped handles.
- Regularly perform smaller cutting tasks.
- Want a particular handle design, such as one made for left-handed use.
These are general preferences rather than fixed rules.
Some resin-handled scissors are larger and heavier than all-stainless models, while some metal-handled designs are comfortable enough for extended use.
I'd also consider whether the scissors are detachable, their overall size and the shape of the cutting edges.
The best handle material won't compensate for blades that aren't suited to the food you're preparing.
Are All-Stainless or Resin-Handled Kitchen Scissors Better?
Both have clear advantages, and I wouldn't consider one material an automatic sign of higher quality.
All-stainless scissors offer a simple, often seamless construction that's particularly appealing if you value straightforward cleaning and a substantial feel.
Resin-handled scissors provide more flexibility in grip design and can be lighter or more comfortable, particularly for everyday food preparation.
If I were choosing a single pair for general home use, I'd place greater importance on handle comfort, weight and intended use than on the material alone.
Someone who prefers a solid, all-metal tool may be very happy with a forged stainless-steel pair. Someone who regularly cuts smaller ingredients may find a lighter elastomer-handled design more comfortable.
Ultimately, the better choice is the pair that feels manageable, cuts the foods you prepare most often and is straightforward to keep clean.